Pompei and Work Part II

Seventeen days later I get a response from the university's legal office. (Why we are going through them I don't know, but that's who was contacted in this matter)
My Letter
My name is Erin ******* and I am an employee of the***********. I believe******** contacted your office recently about a request I had regarding allowing my dog guide in training to accompany me to work. I requested this out of curtsy truthfully, as knew my legal rights as a dog guide raiser…or at least I thought I did. She stated that your office allowed that it was within her legal rights to deny my dog guide in training entry.

I was surprised to hear this, as I knew the TN law had been amended in 2003 to grant puppy raisers and guide dogs in training the same access rights as fully trained service dogs. But just to check I went and looked at the Tennessee Acts of 1955 Title 62; 62-7-112- Guide Dogs to be Admitted- Penalties.

62-7-112(B)(ii)For purposes of this section, “dog guide in training” shall include dogs being raised for an accredited school for training dogs guides, provided that a dog being raised for such purposes is (1) being held on a leash and  is under the control of the raiser or trainer who shall  have available for inspection credentials from the accredited school for which the dog is being raised, and (2) wearing a collar, leash, or other appropriate apparel or device that identifies such dog with the accredited school for which it is being raised. “Dog Guide In Training” shall also include the socialization process that occurs with such dog’s trainer or raiser prior to the dog’s advanced training, provided that such socialization process is under the authorization of an accredited school.

I am currently raising a pup for the Guide Dog Foundation for the Blind in Smith Town NY, and part of the reason I am raising this pup, is so that it can come with me wherever I need to be.My question to you is, am I reading this law wrong? Do I not have access rights as a dog guide raiser?


Their Response: 
My understanding of the relevant facts is as follows.  You are employed by the *************.   You are also a volunteer puppy walker who is raising a puppy for the Guide Dog Foundation for the Blind that one day may become a dog guide in training.  You wish to bring the puppy to work with you. ********* sent you the attached letter explaining why you are not permitted to bring the dog to work. If the above facts are incorrect, please let me know.

Tennessee Code Annotated Section 62-7-112 requires that the university permit dog guide trainers and their dogs access to the university at certain places and times.  This statute does not seem to apply to your circumstances for at least two reasons.  First, my understanding is that you are not a dog guide trainer, but instead are a volunteer puppy walker, and the statute applies only to dog guide trainers.   Second, the statute does not mandate that the University provide access to dog guides in training and their trainers in all places at all times.  Specifically, it does not require that a trainer (or a volunteer puppy walker) be permitted to bring a dog to work.  Section 62-7-112(B)(i) makes it illegal to “…refuse to permit a dog guide trainer to enter such place or to make use of the accommodations provided in those places, when the accommodations are available, for the reason that the dog guide trainer is being led or accompanied by a dog guide in training...”  Even if you were a dog guide trainer for the purposes of the statute, neither you nor the dog is being denied access to the police department because you are being led or accompanied by a dog guide in training. Rather, as ************’s attached letter makes clear, you are being denied access with your dog during work hours because the police department is concerned that the dog may interfere with your work activities and those of your co-workers.  If either you or the Guide Dog Foundation for the Blind has legal support for a different position, I would appreciate seeing it.

Please understand that neither the ********** in general nor the *********** in particular, is attempting to be critical of your very worthwhile activities.  Rather, the Police Department is focusing on its mission of keeping the campus safe.

Is it just me, or did they totally ignore the new section of the law that was added? 

Comments

Oops! Shoulda read the revised piece completely! That's awesome that it specifically says before advanced training! Yes, they're mistaken in that part definitely!
Universities can be frustrating since they're not technically a "public" place, they are private property. Beyond that, the law is interpreted in different ways, dogs in training with puppy raisers are generally not, legally, included in the state statutes stating that dogs in training have access because puppy raisers are not service dog trainers by definition. Yes, we train them, but we're not legal trainers. Many places of employment refuse access since the actual workplace tends to not be "public" and realisticly, while frustrating, it sounds like the legal department/your employer is completely within their legal rights to refuse you access with Pompei. I know it's frustraing, I'm sorry you're dealing with this!
Seems to me they are mistaken. Not sure if you want to keep fighting them on this, but to me it reads that you are in the right. Have you checked with GDF for help, since your state law specifically allows pups before advanced training?
Hey Erin, I'd check with GDF or even put in a call to a lawyer for a better interpretation of the law since it doesn't it doesn't specifically address access with pups in training to your place of employment during business hours. I don't think they can allow you to bring the dog to work but not during your business hours? I don't see how those circumstances can be any different in the eyes of the law, but that's why I'm not a lawyer.

Either way it's disappointing that they're being difficult about it.

When I lived in Massachusetts I raised a pup for Guiding Eyes and my employer would not let me bring my pup in training to work with me, even though puppy raisers have the same rights as the disabled do under ADA. I didn't know that at the time and per the school's recommendation didn't push it which wasn't a big deal because I was co-rasing him anyway, but now I wish I would have....

Good luck and keep us updated.
ok just to clarify because I was half asleep when I wrote my comment last night... When I looked at the laws last night MA vs TN for example, the language of the law is different, so in MA the law specifically says raisers have the same rights as the disabled under ADA. In MA there would be no question whatsoever concerning bringing a pup to work; it would be considered discrimination to not allow you to do so. However the language of the law you quoted (and on the site) in TN is specific and limiting to allowing you access to public places, etc with a pup in training and does not implicitly grant you all the same rights as listed in ADA. I still think, and excuse my language, that what they told you is bull shit, but the language of the law is not entirely clear and they're taking advantage of that.


Not sure what that means you do from here, but the reply back did leave it open for your response, so I'd go for it after doing some more research.
Erin said…
Universities can be frustrating since they're not technically a "public" place, they are private property. Beyond that, the law is interpreted in different ways, dogs in training with puppy raisers are generally not, legally, included in the state statutes stating that dogs in training have access because puppy raisers are not service dog trainers by definition. Yes, we train them, but we're not legal trainers. Many places of employment refuse access since the actual workplace tends to not be "public" and realisticly, while frustrating, it sounds like the legal department/your employer is completely within their legal rights to refuse you access with Pompei. I know it's frustraing, I'm sorry you're dealing with this!
Erin said…
Seems to me they are mistaken. Not sure if you want to keep fighting them on this, but to me it reads that you are in the right. Have you checked with GDF for help, since your state law specifically allows pups before advanced training?

Popular Posts